Austin, David, & Johnny

27:49

Jay's Amateur Straight Guys

Cowboy & Brock / James & Brock

Twink Amateur

15:02

Jay's Amateur Straight Guys

Lane, Dylan & Omar!!! Remastered in HD

Amateur Big Cock

0:39

Jay's Amateur Straight Guys

Mega Hit "straight Guys First Time"

Amateur Big Cock

1:34:59

Jay's Amateur Straight Guys

Lane & Skyler / Rodd VS Rod / Chad / Chad2 / Alex

Amateur Bareback

1:19:17

Jay's Amateur Straight Guys

Gay orgy with KazSnake and Aaron John Robbie

Twink Amateur

25:46

Jay's Amateur Straight Guys

Bryan & Xavier / Jebb & Jay!

Amateur Blowjob

38:03

Jay's Amateur Straight Guys

Straight Boy Peter Fucks Brick / Rodney get his 1st gay BJ

Amateur Blowjob

15:23

Jay's Amateur Straight Guys

Cowboy & Nate

Amateur Big Cock

7:12

Jay's Amateur Straight Guys

Jay & Marc's Private Collectio Vol 3 - Acolyte Meets His Master Flipflop Fuckfest

Twink Amateur

0:39

Jay's Amateur Straight Guys

Cameron & Jay Late Nite @ the Studio in Kc

Twink Amateur

0:40

Jay's Amateur Straight Guys

Lee Fucks Trip in HD!

Twink Amateur

0:40

Jay's Amateur Straight Guys

Two Horny Straight Guys and One Spicy Ginger Fuck

Twink Amateur