James with Jay in 2K!

0:39

Jay's Amateur Straight Guys

Ray and Jay - Then Ray and Brock

Amateur Big Cock

0:57

Jay's Amateur Straight Guys

3 Boys in a Bed with Ass Eating

Twink Amateur

1:21:12

Jay's Amateur Straight Guys

Dirk/DJ/JD/TomAdamBryan/JaredGuzzoBryan

Twink Amateur

0:39

Jay's Amateur Straight Guys

Dirk Brock & David - Dirk Fucks Brock so Hard Brock Blows His Load with a Cock in His Ass!!

Amateur Big Cock

14:17

Jay's Amateur Straight Guys

Shane's Ass Tastes Great

Twink Amateur

14:22

Jay's Amateur Straight Guys

Tanner's a Hot Hairy Straight Boy

Amateur Blowjob

1:06:04

Jay's Amateur Straight Guys

Jay's three plays 11 : Jebb, Greg & Ben, and Todd & Joey!

Amateur Blowjob

1:24:05

Jay's Amateur Straight Guys

Let your freak flag fly!

Amateur Blowjob

30:21

Jay's Amateur Straight Guys

Tom and Bryan play a stake game of truth or dare!

Amateur Blowjob

0:39

Jay's Amateur Straight Guys

Giovanni - Horny Straight Guy

Man Amateur

11:43

Jay's Amateur Straight Guys

Rod Fucks Crow's Ass - and These Two Look Alike - Remastered in 1080p

Twink Amateur

0:39

Jay's Amateur Straight Guys

Cory & Walter

Twink Amateur