James with Jay in 2K!

32:17

Jay's Amateur Straight Guys

Dylan Plows Brian / Dylan & Craig

Twink Amateur

25:22

Jay's Amateur Straight Guys

Tom Adam & Bryan (4K)

Amateur Big Cock

28:50

Jay's Amateur Straight Guys

Jay Fucks his massage therapist bareback!

Amateur Bareback

1:21:12

Jay's Amateur Straight Guys

Dirk/DJ/JD/TomAdamBryan/JaredGuzzoBryan

Twink Amateur

44:35

Jay's Amateur Straight Guys

Alex gets Fucked. Axle Fucks Brock

Amateur Bareback

24:53

Jay's Amateur Straight Guys

Karma & Cypher Rowan Cums Twice - and I swallow Twice!

Amateur Blowjob

8:56

Jay's Amateur Straight Guys

Andrew and James

Twink Amateur

0:57

Jay's Amateur Straight Guys

3 Boys in a Bed with Ass Eating

Twink Amateur

0:39

Jay's Amateur Straight Guys

Fuck Fest 2 - A compilation of Fuck Five Fuck Films

Amateur Bareback

0:39

Jay's Amateur Straight Guys

David and Scott Remastered in HD

Twink Amateur

0:39

Jay's Amateur Straight Guys

Ken Mack & James

Twink Amateur

0:40

Jay's Amateur Straight Guys

Two Horny Straight Guys and One Spicy Ginger Fuck

Twink Amateur